Top Menu

Pence Bill to Defund Planned Parenthood Passes House

A longtime anti-abortion crusader, Pence has three times previously tried to cut off legislative funding, called Title X, for any group that provides abortions. The money cannot be used to pay for abortions, and Pence has not argued that Planned Parenthood has used the funds to do so. But he argues that cutting off support for millions of women’s health clinics would cut off their ability to perform the procedure. “We should end the day when the largest abortion provider is the largest recipient of [Title X] federal funding,” he said. – POLITICO

Yo, Cecil Richards. I told you so.

This is what happens when organizations allow the Right an inch.

Planned Parenthood cannot use any federal funds for abortions services. Pence’s legislation denies funding for HIV testing and other services, but was drawn up because the Right doesn’t like what Planned Parenthood does beyond their federal funding, which is to provide abortion services.

Of course, Speaker Pelosi and Pres. Obama aided this move rightward on women’s health care when they legitimized Stupak-Pitts, with the President signing an Executive Order to legitimize the move to codify the Hyde Amendment in law.

During the health care debate Ms. Richards said she had no problems with the Democratic compromise on women’s freedoms, as Blue Dog Dems applauded the moves.

You had to either be an idiot, born yesterday, a Blue Dog, or a man to fall for what the Democrats did to women in the health care law.

On the other side you have the Live Action hoax targeting Planned Parenthood, which helped stoke Rep. Pence, all of it a carefully planned assault that culminated in the House vote today. Regardless of what happens in the Senate, the Right’s success today will have repercussions going forward; we’ll see a lot more of Mike Pence, for one thing.

Rep. Jerry Nadler called what Pence and his allies did a Bill of Attainder, which is unconstitutional. His remarks are below.

“Madam Chairman, I am not going to repeat all of what has been said about the Republican war on women, about the fact that the Republican majority was elected pledging jobs and all we see is a war on various social services and women and nothing about jobs. But I am going to say this: I have been listening very carefully to the supporters of this amendment, to Mr. Pence and others, and what do I hear? I hear that we must punish Planned Parenthood by defunding them because they have committed a number of sins.

“Sin Number 1 — they perform abortions. They are a very large abortion provider, and even though none of those abortions are paid for with federal funds — that is prohibited under the Hyde amendment, however you read it — ‘we don’t like Planned Parenthood because they are a large abortion provider.’

“Number two — ‘we don’t like Planned Parenthood because they have committed allegedly various terrible things.’ Some provocateurs went into their offices and said that they were representing sex workers and they were offered services, and any organization that is willing to do this should not get federal funds.

“We are going to punish Planned Parenthood, number one, because they are a large abortion provider and we don’t like abortion providers; and, number two, because they do other things which, if in fact they do, which I don’t think they do, but if in fact they do, they are bad things.

“There is a major problem with this. There is a major problem with this rhetoric and with this reasoning. And, by the way, the CR to which this is an amendment eliminates Title X family planning funding anyway, so it will eliminate most of the funds that go to Planned Parenthood. But whatever funds that are available, they can go to other people to provide those services, not Planned Parenthood, because ‘we don’t like Planned Parenthood for various reasons.’

“A bill that punishes someone, some person or organization who is named or is identifiable, by legislative action is called a bill of attainder. That is the definition of a bill of attainder: A legislative punishment, penalty, a legislative penalty, a legislative-enacted penalty — in this case, no funding — directed at some identifiable person or organization to punish them for something.

“Article I, Section 9 says, ‘No bill of attainder or ex post facto law shall be passed’ — a fundamental foundation of constitutional law.

“If Planned Parenthood or anybody else is doing terrible things and ought to be punished, that is up to the courts. If, indeed, Planned Parenthood is trafficking with sex traffickers, let them be prosecuted. If, indeed, Planned Parenthood is doing anything illegal, let them be prosecuted. Let the organization be prosecuted. Let the individual employees who are doing these things be prosecuted at law. That is our system. But you don’t punish an organization because they are doing something of which you don’t approve.

“Now, if you want to say we don’t think that there ought to be any contraceptive services in the United States and therefore we are going to have no Title X funding, the CR does say that. I don’t agree with it, but it is constitutional. But, to say that if we have Title X funding, if we have maternal services funding, none of it can go to Planned Parenthood, it can go to somebody else, but not Planned Parenthood, that is a legislatively enacted punishment because Planned Parenthood is or is allegedly doing things of which you don’t approve.

“Now, I heard a lot at the beginning of this Congress about how we have to make sure that we adhere to the Constitution. This is a bill of attainder, because it is a legislatively enacted punishment of a named organization because that organization is doing things, or is allegedly doing things, of which we don’t approve.

“So I submit that, in addition to all the other reasons why this shouldn’t be done that have been enacted here, this is flatly unconstitutional, and I challenge anyone to say how this is not a bill of attainder. Again, the black letter definition of a bill of attainder is a legislatively enacted penalty aimed at some person or organization that is identifiable, named right here, for some reason, that they have done various things, provided abortions, done illegal things or otherwise.

“So, in addition to all the other problems, this amendment is unconstitutional and will be struck down by the courts if it should pass.”

It doesn’t matter what happens in the courts later.

Today the Right won and Democrats helped them do it.

, , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.
.... a writer is someone who takes the universal whore of language
and turns her into a virgin again.  ~ erica jong